CONTACT

DONATE

Effectiveness of livestock protection interventions against wolves

 · Shared by : Igor Khorozyan
 · Last update : 8 July 2020
Download in PDF
Icon

Initiative
description

Icon
Icon

Implementation, use
and maintenance

Icon
Icon

To go
further

Icon
Icon

Comments

Icon

Initiative
description

Icon
Leader name
Igor Khorozyan
Icon
Entity type
University Institute
Icon
Launching Date
1 January 2019
Icon
Assessment initiative
Assessed
Icon
Initiative Type
Preventing access
Icon
Wildlife species
Wolf
Icon
Issues
Livestock
Icon
Intervention area
Worldwide
Global

BACKGROUND

Wolves cause substantial losses to livestock and other domestic animals globally and therefore are strongly disliked by local people. Global reviews of published studies are needed to identify and apply the most effective interventions of livestock protection.

DESCRIPTION

We used the literature analysis to quantify the effectiveness of livestock protection interventions, compare it across interventions, and find the best interventions for wider applications. The most effective were fencing (electric fences, electrified fladry, night shelters), deterrents, calving control and herding.

Effectiveness was measured as the relative risk (RR), which was transformed to the percentage of damage reduction (DR) for easy interpretation. The formula is simple: DR = (1-RR)*100%. RR is the probability of damage when an intervention is applied divided by the probability of damage without an intervention. The formula of the relative risk is also simple: RR = (nt/Nt)/(nc/Nc), where nt is the number of losses (livestock, beehives, etc.) with the intervention, Nt is the total number of the resource with the intervention (livestock, beehives etc.), nc is the number of losses without the intervention and Nc is the total number of resource without the intervention. The letter "t" stands for treatment (with intervention) and "c" for control (without intervention).

Interventions are effective when RR is less than 1, ineffective at RR = 1 and counter-productive (interventions produce more damage) when RR is higher than 1. Interventions are most effective when RR = 0, i.e. no losses are inflicted when the intervention is applied (nt = 0).

PRINCIPLE

Literature search, data collection and analysis

CONDITIONS OF SUCCESS

Intensive search for appropriate literature
Appropriate quantification of effectiveness (e.g., correlational studies are irrelevant as they only show trends, but not causal effects)


Advantages

  • - Importance for researchers and practitioners

Disadvantages

  • - Many applications of interventions are apparently not published and remain unknown
Icon
Icon

Implementation, use
and maintenance

IMPLEMENTATION

Icon
Workforce
-
Icon
Workload
-
Icon
Training
-
Icon
Training duration
-
Icon
Financial cost
-
Icon
Currency financial cost
-

IMPLEMENTATION KEY STEPS

-

EQUIPMENTS

  • -

USE & MAINTENANCE

Icon
Workforce
-
Icon
Workload
-
Icon
Training
-
Icon
Training duration
-
Icon
Financial cost
-
Icon
Currency financial cost
-
Icon
Annual period of use
-
Icon
Daily period of use
-

STEPS OF USE

-

EQUIPMENTS

  • -
Icon
Icon

To go
further

Icon Contact igor.khorozyan@biologie.uni-goettingen.de
Icon Internet links
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2019.e00868
Icon Funding opportunities -

Icon Documentations
-

This initiative does not have a video yet

Icon
Icon

Comments

Be the first to write a comment about this initiative

Afrikaans Arabic Bengali Catalan Chinese (Traditional) Czech Dutch Finnish French German Greek Hindi Hungarian Indonesian Italian Kurdish (Kurmanji) Portuguese Russian Spanish Swahili